*I wrote this article for a Canadian job search site. The editor refused to publish it. His response and my retorts are below the article.
Working in one company or field, from graduation till retirement, is almost unheard of these days. For many people, their career goals, life paths and interests alter over time, leading them to change direction at least once or twice, sometimes several times, over a lifetime. Organisations and companies, in fact, the world, is dynamic too and change is inevitable. Success relies on the ability to adapt to change.
At times, choices associated with career interruption are made consciously and thoughtfully, the benefits and risks taken into consideration carefully and the pros and cons weighed up, to help make the best possible decisions to suit financial position and desire. A hybrid career can sometimes only be realised after years in the workforce, through trial and error and can benefit both individuals and companies.
However, sometimes a career can veer away from its initial route unexpectedly, which may lead to uncertainty and even hardship. The most common reasons why people may face career interruption are life events such as starting a family, developing illness or becoming incapacitated by an accident. It is interesting that having a baby can seem like an unfortunate obstacle, particularly for women in the workplace, closely related to getting sick or being injured.
While there are checks and balances in place through employment legislation to prevent discrimination against women of child bearing age who become pregnant, the reality is vastly different and many women find that they are either overlooked for positions from the onset, at the interview stage; they are disregarded when it comes to career opportunities and promotions; or they are being forced to exit the workforce through involuntary resignation and redundancy, usually when flexible work arrangements or accessible and affordable childcare are unavailable.
For women who are embarking deliberately on motherhood, this should be a time of celebration and joy, but unlike men, the fact of their biology means that they will need to juggle child bearing with their career in one way or another. Furthermore, women are not only physically responsible for gestation and birth, often the bulk of domestic labour and child care commitments will fall on them also. In fact, recent Australian census data shows that women are still highly disadvantaged when it comes to unpaid domestic labour. In Canada, the statistics show a similar trend, with women doing 50% more domestic duties than men, and men doing 37% more paid work than women.
It is possible that for some women, embarking on intentional motherhood and facing the prospect of career interruption, may be an opportunity to explore new avenues and pathways to find a better balance between work and life, and perhaps even discover new interests and life goals along the way. Having a baby might be the ideal time to allow life to take on a new direction and to pursue alternative and innovative experiences in relation to work, without ending up unemployed for an extended period.
Career interruption can thus be either avoided altogether or used to one’s own advantage, allowing women to be prepared for the changes and to gain benefits from the disruption to what may have become a stagnant employment situation. Men too should be advocating for more flexible workplaces to allow for better work/life balance, not only when embarking on parenthood, but also in the unfortunate event of illness and injury, resulting in unanticipated career interruption or unemployment.
Here are some tips to avoid career interruption all together, or use an inevitable disruption, as an opportunity to enhance paid employment.
- Negotiate a contract and maternity leave policy, prior to recruitment
This is one of the biggest obstacles women face, because as soon as it becomes known that they are planning to start a family, the discrimination begins. It is wise to keep personal details private at the interview stage. In most instances, it is illegal to be questioned about your plans for child bearing in an interview. This information is irrelevant to your capacity to do a job and cannot be used as grounds for discrimination. It is also important to familiarise yourself with an organisation’s maternity leave and return to work policies. Finding a balance between contract negotiation and disclosure can be tricky, however doing some research early on can be beneficial. Don’t be intimidated about asking questions and reading company material. Also, know your rights. Understand workplace legislation, equip yourself with knowledge to not only protect yourself, but to give you the tools and language to negotiate your terms. Whenever possible, join an industry union.
- Participate in further training and education
Being temporarily away from full-time employment can be a perfect time to update skills and training through further study. There are more options to do this remotely nowadays and this activity can improve your chances of not only returning to your old position or industry, but gaining new employment in circumstances where you find yourself unemployed. Retraining can seem daunting, but brushing up on new technology and innovations, by for example improving computer skills, obtaining an industry related certificate or building on already attained qualifications, will not only keep your mind active and motivated throughout early child rearing, it will ensure you are still “in the loop” so to speak and are not drifting further away from the workforce. It may also be a chance to do a course in something completely different to your current field. Changing career paths is always an option and taking that first step will put you in a better position for when you are ready to re-enter the workforce.
- Impart industry knowledge
Sharing your expertise is also another way to maintain focus and experience, while you are on maternity leave or should you be facing redundancy. You may wish to do this through pathways such as writing or teaching within your field. Both these endeavours can be extremely flexible professions and can be performed on a part-time or casual basis, sometimes at excellent rates, and in the case of writing, may even be done from home. Finding ways to utilise your intellectual property can also help you to refine your interests and strengths and will lead you to more job satisfaction and prosperous endeavours.
- Start your own business
Finding yourself without work may be a signal that there is a better fit for you elsewhere, but it may also indicate that you are capable and prepared to forge your own way in your field of expertise. Running your own business is challenging and requires both an investment of time and finance, but if successful, the benefits are abundant. You may want to start something from scratch, or perhaps invest in an existing business or franchise, whether within your current field or in a new area of interest.
- Sound financial planning
It is always beneficial to live within your means. That is, spending according to your earnings and affordability, and ensuring that a financial safety net exists for when the unforeseen happens. This could mean setting up a high interest savings account as soon as you begin paid employment, that is only accessed in the event of an emergency. Minimising debt is another way to ensure that if career interruption occurs, you are not being burdened by superfluous financial commitments such as outstanding debts or credit cards. Participating in a high yield superannuation scheme, and one that may offer access to your money in the event of financial disruption is worth exploring early also. Having a financial safety net simply means you will have more options to explore new opportunities and avoid career interruption. It can allow you to pay for further study and childcare, while you re-establish yourself in the workforce.
- Advocate for affordable and sustainable healthcare, childcare and education
It is vital as a society that we support public services that are accessible and inexpensive. This means educating ourselves about our governments and choosing wisely when we vote. On a more practical level, we can utilise public health systems and educational institutions, including those that facilitate further and vocational study, and support the provision of community childcare services to enhance the demand for them and improve their quality and availability. When mothers are faced with the prospect of balancing family and work, it is these services that are going to determine how much support they can access to maintain employment choices and financial independence, even if their hours and income are reduced as a result of career interruption.
**************************************************************
* The editor:
Hi Diane,
Thanks for your article. It's well-written, but the content is not there. Here's my feedback:
1) You spend 7 paragraphs introducing the topic. I'm not sure what I should take away from these 7 paragraphs. The topic is how to avoid career interruption when having children. It's mainly targeted at women, but you add a few sentences at the end of the intro for men. You also go into various tangents. Your intro should not be more than 1 paragraph or two. Women facing this issue know about the problem. They read your article looking for solutions, not for a lecture on how difficult or unfair life is.
2) You then go on with tips to avoid career interruption altogether. But the tips that you give don't make sense or are just plain obvious. i) Negotiate a contract or maternity leave policy prior to recruitment. That's not realistic for most people. ii) Training and education. After giving birth, most women struggle to just keep up with the newborn. iii) Same thing for sharing your knowledge while on maternity leave. iv) The rest of the tips are obvious. There aren't any insights.
Thanks for your article. It's well-written, but the content is not there. Here's my feedback:
1) You spend 7 paragraphs introducing the topic. I'm not sure what I should take away from these 7 paragraphs. The topic is how to avoid career interruption when having children. It's mainly targeted at women, but you add a few sentences at the end of the intro for men. You also go into various tangents. Your intro should not be more than 1 paragraph or two. Women facing this issue know about the problem. They read your article looking for solutions, not for a lecture on how difficult or unfair life is.
2) You then go on with tips to avoid career interruption altogether. But the tips that you give don't make sense or are just plain obvious. i) Negotiate a contract or maternity leave policy prior to recruitment. That's not realistic for most people. ii) Training and education. After giving birth, most women struggle to just keep up with the newborn. iii) Same thing for sharing your knowledge while on maternity leave. iv) The rest of the tips are obvious. There aren't any insights.
Sorry, this may sound brutal, but I'm just trying to give you my honest feedback.
Let me know your thoughts.
* My response:
Oh dear. I’m afraid you’ve missed the point entirely and
have inadvertently exposed your own male privilege and internalised gender
bias. Sorry to be brutal. I don’t need a week to think on this, I thought about
it over breakfast while we fed the kids.
I didn’t spend 7 paragraphs merely introducing the topic, I
used those words to tease out the issues. Women are engaged and empowered by
being empathised with and having their experiences validated. I used the
statistics relating to domestic duties in two countries to back it up. I also
included men in the scenario, to highlight how childbearing for women in the
workforce is not dissimilar to a disadvantage like an illness or injury
suffered by men. I also attempted to highlight how men are needed to support women
to avoid career interruption, particularly when they often possess the
structural power to do so, but also within their own households.
I think it is patronising and quite incorrect to suggest
that women are not capable of participating in paid work, study or training
whilst caring for a newborn. That is entirely the attitude of discrimination
creating these barriers in the first place. Two points here. Firstly, where are
their partners? Shouldn’t they be doing 50% of the work and negotiating flexibility
in their own careers to make space for women to preserve theirs? That is why I
mentioned them in the beginning. Not only to include men and make a comparison
to their own possible career disruptions through illness/injury, but also to
make them accountable. The fact is most men won’t participate equally in
domestic duties and child rearing specifically because it is difficult, tedious
and UNPAID work and to preserve their own careers and sanity. Secondly, this
statement is blatantly untrue. I can tell you I wrote and self-published a
novel with TWO newborns and a toddler and recently Senator Larissa Waters
breastfed her baby whilst putting forward a motion in the Australian Federal
Parliament. Google it.
The other tips I mentioned such as maintaining financial
independence and having a monetary safety net are not obvious to women, within
a patriarchal system that largely expects them to abandon their careers and
financial independence, instead becoming dependent on their partners (often
male/husbands – but not always), when they have children. That is the central
point of the whole topic. It is impossible to find 800-1000 words describing
ways in which women can preserve their careers, outside the tips I have given,
within an inherently sexist system, which you have very clearly demonstrated.
This is yours, many men’s and society’s views:
- Women are solely responsible for looking after newborns and can barely cope, so can’t retrain, work part-time or work from home
- Women already know to have a financial safety
net, that’s why they get married and let the man work so they can stay home and
do the housework and look after the baby
I could have written a three-word article to help women
avoid career interruption: don’t have kids!
You also suggest that it is unrealistic to negotiate
maternity leave. Rubbish. This is exactly the type of empowerment women need
and the kind of resistance men need to stop creating in relation to career
interruption. It is absolutely realistic, in fact necessary, for both men and
women to start demanding flexible workplaces in regard to family/life/work
balance. It is not only a woman’s obligation to surrender her financial
independence and her career aspirations to build a family, it should be
everybody’s responsibility to participate in child rearing equally. Including
society in general, which is why I mentioned how we should educate ourselves
about our governments and the structural systems they maintain that for the
most part, disadvantage women. The most progressive nations in the world
already do this. They provide free or at least affordable childcare, they have
school drop off/pick up compatible work hours and don’t depend on the false
economy of working 9am-5pm, focusing instead on productivity not hours sitting
at your desk, and they encourage equality in parenting by both men and women.
I anticipated that you may not be brave enough to include a
feminist perspective on your website. You said you didn’t want me to write
fluff, but I think that is exactly what you wanted. Not an article that
actually empowers women by validating and articulating their lived experiences
and provides them with tools to empower them to maintain an intellectual and
financial pursuit whilst raising children, and demanding that there is someone
to pick up the slack when they surrender some of the burdens associated with
child rearing. By not using articles like this, you are simply alienating 50%
of your market. Don’t underestimate women’s, especially mother’s, capacity to
engage with an academic level, politically rich article. Who knows, it may take
your site to the next level. I know how women think and feel. I am a woman who
writes for and about women. And not women with internalised misogyny and a sad
case of Stockholm Syndrome. Google it.
I’m not surprised you didn’t take anything away from this
article. I didn’t write it for you. I wrote it for your female readers.
This is how I write. It won’t change. If you don’t think it’s a good fit for
your site, we can terminate the relationship here.
PS – I wrote this response in between clearing the breakfast
dishes, changing one nappy, wiping one bum, brushing four sets of teeth
including my own, putting on three sets of fairy wings and preparing morning
tea for three children under four. Women can multi-task, we just need to start
getting paid for it!
* Editor:
I won't be publishing your
article, but I will still pay you for it. I didn't appreciate your reply and
the assumptions that you made. You talk about discrimination, but do you
realize that I probably suffered more discrimination than you, as a visible
minority? The feedback I gave you was as an editor of a site for over 10 years.
And I am a father and took one year off as paternity leave. I know how hard it
is to raise kids. Maybe you and some women can do it as well as advance your
career, but it is a real struggle. My suggestions were from real life
experience. When a new baby is born, the parents want to spend time with them,
not think about career. There's more to life than career. Btw, my wife is a
lawyer and is an accomplished woman who worked hard her whole life. Even she
struggled. I'm glad you can do all that you claim, but I regret to inform you
can most people can't live up to your standards...you should really reconsider how you deal with people.
* My final word:
It's not about living up to standards. It's about removing
obstacles to allow people to struggle less. With all yours and your wife's
experiences, I'm baffled you don't agree that we should have more balance. Of
course people want to spend time with their children, but not at the expense of
their lives and careers outside parenthood. And it's often mothers who are
expected to give up more.
It's interesting that you interpret my assertive response as aggressive. Very telling too.
It seems you are
entitled to be brutal in your criticism and I am not. I suggest asking your
wife and other women in your life to read the article and see what they think
about it.
No comments:
Post a Comment